Ilya called me pretty late in the evening. He told me that in the past week, he had managed to go on two dates: one with a thirty-year-old woman and the other with someone his own age. Now, he said, he finally understood just how different these kinds of dates can be.
I headed over to his garage. Conversations like this aren’t meant for the phone—they’re the kind of stories you have to share in person.
You know how there are some friends you might not see for half a year, but when you finally get together, you just pick right back up as if you parted yesterday? Ilya is one of those friends. We’ve been close since ninth grade, ever since his family moved into our neighborhood that summer. He’s fifty now. He went through a divorce three years ago, and I’ve been married for twenty-six years, so I’m pretty used to listening to other people’s stories with interest.
Ilya’s garage was cozy and warm. An oil heater hummed along, and, as usual, something half-disassembled sat on the workbench. That night, a carburetor took center stage. Next to it was a neatly folded blue knitted scarf. I couldn’t help but wonder: how did a woman’s scarf end up in his garage?
“Have a seat,” Ilya offered, pushing a toolbox over for me. “Just promise you won’t laugh.”
Laughing was the last thing on my mind. I poured some tea from a thermos and made myself comfortable, ready for an interesting story.
Ilya met Vera on a dating site. She was the one who messaged him first, which already took him by surprise. In his profile, he listed his real age and posted a photo of himself in his fishing jacket, holding a zander. He didn’t have high hopes for finding anyone and understood perfectly well how he looked from the outside.
“Can you believe it, she’s only thirty!” he told me, with a tone in his voice that sounded almost youthful. “Thirty years old! I could practically be her father. At first, I thought it was some sort of prank. But she was completely serious and wrote, ‘Let’s meet on Saturday, at the coffee shop on the riverside.’
Ilya got to the meeting spot about twenty minutes early.
For some reason, he bought three tulips, but soon felt awkward about it and put the flowers away in a bag. When Vera arrived, the bouquet stayed hidden inside.
She turned out to be tall, almost the same height as Ilya. Short hair, lively gray eyes—that’s how he remembered her. She ordered some drink with coconut milk, the name of which Ilya could never remember. He, as usual, went for plain black coffee.
“Can you imagine, she figured out right away that I drink black coffee with no sugar,” he said. “How did she know?”
I just shrugged and guessed maybe it was something about the way he looked.
“Right, of course. I must have a face that’s brown-black, then,” Ilya laughed.
Then, as he put it, the real test began. Vera didn’t start sharing about herself, as he had expected. Instead, she began firing off questions—one after another, quickly and insistently, barely giving him any time to gather his thoughts.
She wanted to know where he spent his childhood, what jobs he had done, why his marriage ended, and whether he had any children. When Vera found out that Ilya had a son, she asked how often they saw each other. And surprisingly, he answered honestly: they rarely see each other, and that’s what causes him the deepest pain.
“And she just nodded,” Ilya continued. “She didn’t pity me or try to comfort me by promising that things would get better. She simply nodded, as if she’d checked off some point for herself.”
At that moment, Ilya suddenly realized he was sitting differently: shoulders back, stomach in, carefully choosing his words. Have you ever had that feeling? When you’re with someone and suddenly feel like they’re sizing you up from all sides. And then you can’t help but start acting like a better version of yourself—a little younger, a little smarter, and just a bit more successful than you really are.
“We sat there for an hour and twenty minutes,” Ilya admitted. “And I felt like I’d unloaded an entire train car with my own hands.”
I asked what Vera had managed to share about her own life. He thought for a moment, trying to recall the details.
“Almost nothing, really. She works at an architecture firm, does some interior projects. She lives with her mom and is saving up to get her own place. Oh, and for some reason, she started talking about Plyos.”
“Plyos?”
“Exactly. I happened to mention that in my youth we spent summers there at my aunt’s place. Then she started asking: what year was that, where did we stay, had I ever been to the dance floor by the pier? I said it was 1993 and of course, I went to the dances. She looked at me in a strange way, then burst out laughing.”
“And her laugh,” Ilya added after a pause, “you know, it’s so bright and unstoppable.”
For a while, he stood with his back to me, looking at the shelf lined with jars full of nails.
But that turned out to be just the first part of his story.
The second meeting happened four days later. At this point, Ilya became noticeably animated as he talked about it. Lydia, as he put it, seemed to be sent to him by fate itself. She messaged him on social media after seeing an old graduation photo someone had posted in their group. The message was short: “Ilyusha, is that you? Are you alive?”
“No one has called me Ilyusha in thirty years,” he said, his chin trembling a little. “Only my mother. Well, and one other person.”
I didn’t say anything in response. I knew exactly who he was talking about, even though Ilya hadn’t spoken her name aloud for years. After coming back from Plyos in the summer of ’93, he spent half a year wandering around lost. He wrote letters that were never answered, and one day he gathered them all up and burned them in an old iron barrel in the yard.
Back then I was sixteen, and he was seventeen. That autumn, for the first time, I noticed how a person’s face could change so much in just a few months, as if he had suddenly lived a whole lifetime and grown up overnight.
“Lida?” I asked quietly. “That same one?”
“The very same,” he replied.
This time, they agreed to meet at a small restaurant serving Georgian cuisine. Lida herself picked the place. She arrived by taxi, wearing a long gray coat, and didn’t even try to hide the gray at her temples. Once she settled at the table, she spoke her first words:
“Well, go on, Ilyusha. Tell me everything.”
“Do you know what happened next?” Ilya spread his hands. “I finally felt like I could breathe. For the first time all week. I stopped sucking in my stomach, stopped straightening my back, stopped checking every move I made. I just sat there as myself and spoke the truth about what I was really thinking.”
He talked about that evening for a long time, recalling even the tiniest details. They tried to remember the song that played at the pier every summer, but neither of them could get the second verse quite right.
At one point, Lida calmly took a piece of khachapuri right from his plate, without even asking. She did it so casually, as if they hadn’t been apart for years, but had just seen each other yesterday. She also talked about her husband. They were together for twenty years, and five years ago she buried him. She talked about it steadily, without tears or dramatics.
“With Vera, I always felt like I was being tested, like at an exam,” Ilya finally summed up. “But with Lida, it felt like coming home. That’s the whole difference, you see? With a young woman, you have to prove something—show her you’re not old yet, convince her you’re reliable, that you won’t be a burden. But with a woman your own age, it’s totally different. There’s nothing to explain. She already understands a lot, because she’s gone through similar things herself.”
I nodded in agreement. His reasoning sounded perfectly logical. More than that, there was a certain life wisdom in his words. I was already picturing myself telling my wife this story later in the evening.
But Ilya’s next comment made me stop nodding along.
“By the way,” he added, “Lida also asked me if I see my son often. Almost the exact same words Vera used. I actually wondered for a second: why are both of you so interested in my son?”
I set my mug down on the workbench, right next to that familiar blue scarf.
“Where did that scarf come from?” I asked.
“That one? Vera left it at the coffee shop. I even ran out to catch her and give it back, but she said, ‘Just keep it for now, I’ll get it later.’ She’s a strange girl, isn’t she?”
Strange indeed.
A young woman, just thirty years old, starts showing interest in a man who is fifty. From their very first conversation, she guesses his favorite coffee. She asks questions as if she’s filling out a detailed questionnaire. She’s especially curious about Plyos and the summer of ’93. She still lives with her mother.
But just four days after she disappears from Ilya’s life, Lida suddenly appears—the woman he hasn’t mentioned in over thirty years.
Vera is thirty. No, she’s definitely not his daughter. The thought made me exhale so loudly that Ilya immediately turned to look at me.
“What’s up with you?” he asked.
“Oh, nothing. The tea’s just really hot,” I replied.
But if Vera isn’t his daughter, then who is she?
I tried to ask my next question as casually as possible, like I was just keeping the conversation going:
“So, does Lida live alone now?”
“She lives with her daughter,” Ilya answered, still staring at the heater. “Her girl’s an adult now, I think she’s an architect. Lida says her daughter is wonderful, she just hasn’t bought her own place yet, so they still live together. Hey, why are you looking at me like that?”
I watched my friend and couldn’t help marveling at how the human mind works. Ilya is fifty now. He can take apart a carburetor by feel alone and knows exactly what fish is on the hook just by its bite.
Still, he was only a step away from the answer now. He’d already laid out all the important details for me, one by one, yet somehow couldn’t put them all together.
After all, he hadn’t really been telling me about two different women. This was about one family.
“Ilyush,” I said, surprised myself by using that name. “Does Lida have any pictures of her daughter?”
“I don’t know. She never showed me any. Why do you ask?”
“Ask her to show you some.”
Ilya looked at me for a long time, clearly skeptical. It’s the kind of look you give someone who might be making no sense, but maybe their words actually mean something. Then he grabbed his phone.
It turned out Lida herself had messaged him that morning. Her message said: “Thanks for yesterday evening. My daughter says hi. She says you passed the test.”
Ilya hadn’t thought much about what she wrote. He didn’t understand what test she meant and assumed it was just a family joke. So he just replied with a smiley face.
Now, he opened their chat and read the message aloud. He took his time, saying each word carefully. I watched him and saw his expression slowly change—just like it had all those years ago, when he was only sixteen.
Now let me tell you what really happened. Later, Lida explained the whole story to Ilya herself. They talked over the phone that same evening.
When Lida saw an old graduation photo in their class group chat, she instantly recognized Ilya. But she couldn’t bring herself to write him right away—she spent three whole days thinking about it before making the first move.
Vera noticed her mom kept pacing around the phone and couldn’t seem to calm down. Her daughter asked what was going on, and that’s when Lida shared the story of the summer of ’93.
About a boy from the pier, about feelings that lingered in memory for years, and letters that never reached their destination. Lida’s father was a strict, unyielding man. He found the letters in the mailbox and threw them away, never letting his daughter read them.
She only learned the truth ten years later, when she was sorting through the documents and papers he left behind.
After listening to her mother, Vera suggested:
“Mom, let me find out myself what kind of person he is first. What if he drinks, or has a complicated personality, or is even still married? You really don’t need more disappointment right now.”
After that, everything became pretty straightforward.
It was her mother who told Vera that Ilya preferred black coffee without sugar. She also shared which questions to ask about her son. Lida wasn’t interested in how much money Ilya had or what car he drove. She wanted to know something else: could he take care of those close to him, and how did he treat the people he loved?
Vera herself brought up Plyos. She was curious whether Ilya still remembered those times. Turns out he did—he named the year without any hesitation.
And the blue scarf Vera left with him wasn’t out of forgetfulness. It belonged to her mother.
“So it turns out,” Ilya finally said, “I somehow managed to go on two dates with the same woman.”
“Looks like you did.”
“And all that difference I was so sure about when I told you…”
He fell silent, not finishing the sentence. I didn’t try to continue it for him.
Two months passed. Now, almost every Saturday, Ilya and Lida go out of town to visit Lida’s friend at her country house. Vera often drops by in the evenings, too. She loves debating hockey with Ilya and calls him by his full name. But she does it with such a sly smile that it sounds more like a playful nickname.
Recently, Ilya invited me to his garage again. By then, the carburetor had already been repaired and installed. There were no more parts on the workbench. Just a checkered notebook, where Ilya was writing in his uneven handwriting.
“I’m writing a letter,” he explained when he noticed my glance. “To my son. Vera said: since I once managed to write letters that never reached their recipient, I should be able to write at least one that finally gets to where it needs to go.”
I asked him what happened to the blue scarf.
Ilya smiled and pointed to the hook next to the door. That’s where the scarf was—blue, a bit stretched, hanging beside his fisherman’s jacket. Every time Ilya was about to leave the garage, he would run his hand over it.
That kind of touch is only for something you once lost and now never want to let go of again.